Home GST No Interest Liability If ECL Balance

No Interest Liability If ECL Balance

No Interest Liability If ECL Balance
No Interest Liability If Balance in ECL for Delayed GSTR 3B Filing

Part 50 of The CGST Act was revised to furnish that there can be no curiosity obligation on late submitting of GSTR-3B to the extent of the stability in The Digital Credit score Ledger, the Courts within the following and different instances dominated that curiosity was subjected to be paid even after there was stability within the Digital Money Ledger.

Completely different Circumstances of Excessive Courts

  • Orissa Stvedores Ltd vs. Union of India reported in MANU/OR/1116/2022;
  • RSB Transmission (India) Ltd. vs. Union of India reported in MANU/JH/1260 – 2022-VIL-745-JHR; Learn Order
  • Srinivasa Stampings vs. SPT of GST & CE in W.P.No.7129 of 2021 – 2022-VIL-285-MAD Learn Order
  • P.Ok. Ores P Ltd vs Commissioner of State Tax reported in MANU/OR/236/2022 – 2022-VIL-365-ORI; Learn Order
  • Haji Lal Mohd Biri Works vs. State of Uttar Pradesh reported in (1974) 3 SCC 137 – 1973-VIL-22-SC;
  • Prahlad Rai vs. Gross sales Tax Officer reported in (1991) Supp (2) SCC 612 – 1990-VIL-20-SC;
  • Commissioner of Gross sales Tax vs. Qureshi Crucible reported in (1993) Supp (3) SCC 495 – 1993-VIL-10-SC;
  • Refex Industries vs. Assistant Commissioner of CGST reported in 2020 SCC On-line Mad 587 – 2020-VIL-71-MAD; Learn Order
  • Manasarover Motors P Ltd vs Assistant Commissioner reported in 2020 SCC On-line Mad 28155 – 2020-VIL-524-MAD;
  • The Gross sales Tax Officer vs. Dwarika Prasad Sheo Karan Dass reported in (1977) 1 SCC 22 – 1976-VIL-43-SC;
  • Khazan Chand vs. State of Jammu and Kashmir reported in (1984) 2 SCC 456 – 1984-VIL-12-SC;
Take Into Account of the Following Case

The Madras Excessive Court docket within the matter of M/s EICHER MOTORS LIMITED [2024-VIL-72-MAD] has carried in any other case. The inspiration on which this judgment was delivered is as follows-

1. Part 39(1) and 39(7) of CGST Act (Act) mandate that assesses who’re directed to supply GSTR-3B return below Part 39(1), will “pay” to the Authorities the tax due “earlier than” offering the GSTR-3B return and disclose “tax paid” within the GSTR-3B return.

Part 39(1) and 39(7) states as under:

“39. 6[(1) Every enrolled individual excluding an input service distributor or a non-resident taxable individual or a person who files the tax under the provision of section 10 or section 51 or section 52 will to every calendar month or part thereof, provide, a return, electronically, of inward and outward supplies of goods or services or both, input tax credit availed, tax payable, tax filed and these additional particulars, in these form and manner, and the similar period, as may be specified:

Given that the Government might on the council’s suggestion show a specific class of enrolled individual who provides the return for every quarter on the part thereof, as per these conditions and limitations as might be stated in it.

7[(7) Every registered individual who is needed to provide a return under sub-section (1), excluding the person referred to in the proviso thereto, or sub-section (3) or sub-section (5), shall pay to the Government the tax due according to such return not later, the due date on which he is needed to provide such return:

9 [Given that every registered person providing the return under the proviso to sub-section (1) will pay to the Government, in such manner, and within such time, as may be prescribed,

(a) an amount equivalent to the tax due carrying into account inward and outward supplies of goods or services or both, ITC claimed, tax payable, and such other particulars during a month; or

(b) in place of the amount referred to in clause (a), an amount determined in a way and as per these conditions and restrictions as may be prescribed.]”

Given that every enrolled particular person offering a return below sub-section (2) pays earlier than the Authorities the tax due considering turnover within the State or Union territory, inward provides of products or providers or each, tax payable, and different particulars in 1 / 4, in such type and method, and inside such time, as could also be prescribed.]

2. Part 49(1) mandates that quantities deposited through assesses might be credited to the digital money ledger (ECL) of the taxpayer. Rule 87(6) & 87(7) of The CGST Guidelines (Guidelines) additionally specifies {that a} CIN would solely be generated after the Authorities’s accounts are credited.

Part 49(1) and Rule 87(6) & 87(7) specified as-

“Part 49(1) Each deposit created for tax, curiosity, penalty, charge, or any further quantity through an individual via web banking or through the use of credit score or debit playing cards or Nationwide Digital Fund Switch or Actual Time Gross Settlement or via this different mode and topic to those situations and restrictions as could also be specified, shall be credited to the digital money ledger of those people to be carried in a manner as could also be stipulated.”

“Rule 87 (6) On profitable credit score of the quantity to the associated authorities account stored within the approved financial institution, a Challan Identification Quantity might be generated via the accumulating financial institution and that might be demonstrated within the challan.

87(7) On the receipt of the Challan Identification Quantity from the accumulating financial institution, the outlined quantity might be credited to the digital money ledger of the particular person on whose behalf the deposit has been made and the widespread portal make accessible a receipt to this impression.”

3. The RBI has made the quantities of so deposited earlier than the accounts of the Authorities as clarified via the RBI in FAQ 8 on 14th April 2020. The Clarification (a) to Part 49 learn with Part 49(11) specifies that the date when quantities are deposited is the date when the Authorities’s accounts are credited.

The pertinent extracts of provisions are as below –

“FAQ 8. What’s the function of RBI within the Items and Service Tax regime?

For accounting of all GST collections within the respective authorities accounts the Reserve Financial institution of India is the aggregator. Company banks acquire the GST for challans generated through taxpayers on-line on the report of the GST portal the collections for settlement to authorities accounts to RBI. RBI has eased the GST fee through taxpayers straight into authorities accounts at RBI through the use of NEFT / RTGS fee choices supplied within the GST portal.”

“Part 49 (11) The place any quantity has been transferred earlier than the digital money ledger below this Act, it is going to be thought of to be deposited within the mentioned ledger as furnished in sub-section (1).]”

Clarification- For this section-

“(a) the credit score date to the account of the Authorities within the approved financial institution will thought of to be the date of deposit within the digital money ledger;”

4. GST assortment numbers arrived at via the Authorities are made on the grounds of the quantity deposited within the digital money ledger and never the quantity set off on the time of submitting the GSTR-3B returns.

5. The Authorities makes use of the cash of the ECL. There isn’t a monetary loss for the Authorities. if the cash within the Digital Money Ledger (ECL) shouldn’t be set off by GSTR-3B. It shall be ruinous for the exchequer if the quantities will not be approved for use.

6. Beneath Part 54(12) in case there’s a delay from the Authorities aspect. in refunding the quantity within the ECL availed through taxpayer past a time, it must pay curiosity. If the quantities in ECL weren’t utilized by the Authorities, in what manner shall it pay curiosity on a delayed refund?

“Part 54 (12) through which a refund is stored below sub-section (11), the taxable particular person will, however something included in part 56, be approved to curiosity on the similar fee not surpassing 6% as notified on the division’s suggestions, if because of the plea or further proceedings, he turns into expert for refund.”

The controversy may not finish as going ahead the federal government may study the actual that-

  1. Part 49(3) mandates that the quantity accessible in ECL is used for tax fee and so on. Part 39 calls for that the GSTR-3B have to be filed after ‘fee’ of taxes through utilizing the quantities accessible in ECL and Digital Credit score Ledger. The ultimate fee is incurred post-filing GSTR-3B and Curiosity is for tax paid after the due date.

Learn Additionally: Latest Excessive Court docket Ruling on GST Return Mismatch Circumstances

Part 49 (3) expresses that the quantity accessible within the digital money ledger may be utilized to make any fee for the tax, curiosity, penalty, charges, or some other quantity liable to receives a commission below the provisions of this Act or the foundations made thereunder in a manner and topic to those situations and in a time as could also be specified.

  1. Rule 61(1) of CGST Guidelines furnishes that each particular person ought to file his GSTR-3B return throughout the twentieth of the month as mandated below Part 39 of the CGST Act. Rule 61(2) calls for that on the time of submitting the GSTR-3B, the tax will solely be launched.

Rule 61(1) and 61(2) state as below

Rule 61 (1) Each registered particular person will present the return in FORM GSTR-3B, electronically through the widespread portal straight or through the Facilitation Centre notified via the Commissioner, as outlined below

(2) Each particular person enrolled wanted to supply the return, below sub-rule (1) will, topic to the provisions of part 49, launch his obligation for tax, curiosity, penalty, charges or some other quantity liable to be paid below the Act or the provisions of this Chapter via debiting the digital money ledger or digital credit score ledger and possess the data within the return in FORM GSTR-3B.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here